The BEST thing they did with Lucas’s character in season four was making him want to be popular without making him suddenly a dick or making him ‘lose sight’ of 'what’s important,’ ie his friends.
He makes it so clear that he is doing this for all of them, and he never stops reaching out. When he finds out they’re in danger, he literally runs god knows how far or how long to find them. He never resents Max for pulling away and he doesn’t try to bring the potential drama with his friends into the Upside Down.
I love him so much 😭
The thing is… I fully don’t think he even “wants to be popular” per se. I think he just wants to play basketball and have both his current friends and his basketball friends. It’s everybody else who puts all kinds of value judgments on that. He just wants to play basketball and get on with his teammates. It’s other people who bring their popularity damage to that.
So in S4 E1 (The Hellfire Club), Lucas has this to say to Mike and Dustin re: the scheduling conflict:
Lucas: “If I get in good with these guys, I’ll be in the popular crowd, and then you guys will be too.”
“Look, I’m tired of being bullied. I’m tired of girls laughing at us. I’m tired of feeling like a loser. We came to high school wanting things to be different. Right? So now we have that chance. I skip tonight, that’s all out the window. So I’m asking you guys, as a friend, just talk to Eddie. Get him to move Hellfire. Come to my game. Please.”
He wasn’t in particularly close with the basketball team - the championship game was, by his own metric, a calculated move to get ahead socially as a means of protection. One of the things the show started out handling fairly well in S1 and S2 imo was how Lucas’s race sets him apart in Hawkins from even the rest of The Party. (Bullies calling him “midnight” in S1, the Venkman vs Winston Halloween costume fight between him and Mike in S2, and then Billy’s overt racism towards him in S2). By season 3 (probably as a function of the show’s rising popularity 👀👀), that aspect of his character arc is pretty much struck from the scripts. The writers had a prime opportunity to address it again in S4 with Lucas’s difference in approach to high school social politics than Mike or Dustin but they got riiiiiight up to the line and (imo) chickened out.
Yes, he likes playing basketball, but the team are not really his friends. He overtly lies to them about his involvement in Hellfire, pawning it off as his sister’s hobby. He doesn’t try to convince the team of Eddie’s innocence through his own involvement, which would indicate he has true camaraderie to leverage. Hell, the rest of the team doesn’t know Lucas well enough to call his bluff until they obtain yearbook club photos that implicate him.
Out of the entire Party, Lucas is the most pragmatic - one could argue that this is a skill he’s honed over the years as a Black kid in a predominantly white town. Same for being the least trusting member. He hasn’t been insulated from the ugly realities of society the way Mike and Dustin, and to a lesser extent Will, have been even though all four of them have been outcasts together. Lucas explains that he’s making moves to protect himself (and hopefully his friends) and, in one of their less than stellar moments, Mike and Dustin refuse to meet him halfway by giving the world’s most half-assed attempt to get Eddie to move the campaign.
IMO given everything we learn about Eddie in *just* that episode, Dustin and Mike could have absolutely made a compelling case to postpone using Eddie’s own “Munson Doctrine” as the rationale and gotten him to move it while earning his respect but they wanted Eddie’s approval more than they wanted to support Lucas at his game, but that’s not the point
Forgive me, I literally finished rewatching S4 earlier this week.






































